[Nettime-bold] More on Genoa: The Magical Mystery Tour of the Fake Black Bloc

["geert lovink" <geert@xs4all.nl>]

From: Wu-ming Yi [mailto:roberto.bui@libero.it]
Sent: Montag, 23. Juli 2001 08:11
Subject: The Magical Mystery Tour of the Fake Black Bloc in Genoa

I was in Genoa, I came back worn out, angry, disappointed and feverish,
with the ligaments of my knees destroyed and completely out of voice, and I
say: do not go hunting anarchists, do not criminalize the international
Black Bloc. It is our duty to draw distinctions between the Black Bloc and
what happened in Genoa. It is our duty not to charge with being a
carabiniere in disguise anyone who took direct action in Genoa. Pogroms and
paranoid conspiracy theories do not belong to our culture.
Last friday in Genoa were some German anarchists of the Schwartze Block.
They hit such precise targets as banks and big corporate offices. They had
no intention to attack other demonstrators. On Saturday a Dutch journalist
of Vrij Neederland magazine met them while they were packing and maybe
going back to Germany. They told him they were pissed-off because of what
other "men in black" had done. In fact what went on saturday had very
little to do with the BB's modus operandi: the BB has a method. One may
disagree with them, and yet they have a method and go their own way without
interfering with other forms of action. On the contrary, in Genoa the
carabinieri escorted the trashers all day long, and never charged them, not
because they were too fast and informal, as someone commented. No, they had
all the time to go inside banks, trash them accurately and set them on
fire, an operation which requires more than a quarter of an hour. In the
meanwhile, the carabinieri hanged on in the street, _waiting for them_.
When the trashers went out, the magical mystery tour went on. The
carabinieri quietly accompanied the trashers to the places where many other
people (belonging to the GSF) were demonstrating in other ways, as if they
were walking their dogs. There are hundreds of testimonies. All along the
path the men in black attacked small shops, set fire to cars that certainly
didn't belong to millionaires, destroyed very little gas stations and so
on. Then they were  unchained in the square where hundreds of members of
the Lilliput network were doing a sit-in. The carabinieri followed them and
beat up women and children, boy scouts, peaceful demonstrators.
Then carabinieri and trashers left again and went to the convergence center
in Piazza Kennedy. The carabinieri assaulted the place, then the merry
party directed to Brignole station and bumped into the demonstration by the
civil disobedience bloc, which was still far from the Red Zone. The
carabinieri charged the demonstrators. In the meanwhile, some of those fake
Black Blocsters broke into the ranks of the white overalls and assaulted
some comrades. A very big comrade from Venice-based squat "Rivolta" was
knocked down by a guy that surely was a very well trained martial artist.
After that, the carabinieri kept attacking the demo for seven hours, while
people were trying to go back to Carlini Stadium. The last attack took
place less than 600 yards from the camping. The men in black had completely
disappeared.
This has nothing to do with the praxis of the Black Bloc. In fact many
people saw these fake black blocsters coming out of carabinieri vans,
putting on the balaklava and starting to raise hell, trashers discussing
plans with marshalls, carabinieri giving crowbars to fake black blocsters
etc.
The press is reporting these stories, and the national TV is showing
shocking footage.
On June 19th, after Gothenburg, the White Overalls of Bologna and the Wu
Ming collective put into circulation a document titled "Stop the
Encirclement of the Black Bloc". Here it is:
-------------
"The Black Bloc is no bullshit. It should not be trivially associated with
vandalism and irrational devastation. It is an informal network of affinity
groups, mostly - but not exclusively - anarchist ones, and it extends all
over North America and continental Europe. They've been active for years,
elaborate strategies and tactics and are willing to transform them in
relation to contexts, alliances and aims. It should be clear that so far
the Black Bloc hasn't manifested itself in Italy.
As the recent history of the movement proves, the Black Bloc are
not  static and can adopt different tactis and seek "cross-fertilization"
like they did in Quebec City during the anti-FTAA mobilisation. In those
days they acted in full respect of the town and its inhabitants, and
concentrated all efforts in tearing down the "Wall of Shame". They even
chose to use symbols and practices devised by the white overalls (pads,
shields, position holding etc.) and co-operated with other affinity groups
in the street.
In Gothenburg the Black Bloc talked with the white overalls and decided to
take action in a common frame including more peaceful protesters. Troubles
started when the vast majority of spokespersons and coordinators were
"preventively" arrested during the thursday night raid. The morning after,
the cops cut in half the demo and isolated a section of it, which was
labelled as "Black Bloc". These demonstrators could only defend themselves
by throwing stones, and a few shop windows were broken [...] The peak of
police violence was reached at an apparently peaceful moment: on friday
night, when the cops surrounded a park where hundreds of youth had
organized a rave party. They attacked the ravers, which tried to resist
unbecomingly [well, you can't always be stylish], then the police fired.
Certainly the rave was not organized by the Black Bloc.
Black Blocsters are political activists, we may disagree with their praxis
and theory, but we don't deem them as brainless Pavlov dogs foaming at the
sight of truncheons.
Moreover, they are more fanciful than people think: a few months ago Black
Blocsters split off a demo in Buffalo, entered a destitute neighborhood and
picked up garbage. When journalists asked what the fuck they were doing,
they answered: "You wrote that we would trash the town, we decided to pick
up the trash!".
We're witnessing a very serious attempt at criminalizing this section of
the movement. We refuse to save our ass to the detriment of the Black Bloc,
we regard them as a fully legitimate part of the movement and refuse any
distinction between "good protesters" and "bad protesters".
White Overalls of Bologna / Wu Ming"
-----------------------------------
My opinion is not even an opinion, for it is fully supported by testimonies
and video documentation: last friday six or seven infiltrated carabinieri
channeled and directed the (just, albeit blind) anger of hundreds of
anarchist kids who should have known better. The same thing may have taken
place saturday. Reluctantly, we decided to keep people with clubs or stones
out of our demo. We certainly rejected several real provocators who called
us "cops" and probably were cops themselves. Most likely we happened to
beat up the occasional wrong guy, who knows? If that happened we're very
sorry, but we had to defend our affinity group and prevent infiltrations
and aggressions. A Black Blocster told my fellow comrade Wu Ming 5: "You
like to give orders, uh? You communist!". Well, that hurts. I can assure
you that we DO NOT like to give orders.
Instead of starting a witch hunt, we should keep in mind that not all
anarchists are black blocsters and not all black blocsters are cops in
disguise. On the other hand, it is necessary to re-think a tactic that can
be infiltrated and deviated so easily. This is up to the people who adopt
that tactic, but it also concerns those who suffer the consequences of such
permeability.




_______________________________________________
Nettime-bold mailing list
Nettime-bold@nettime.org
http://www.nettime.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/nettime-bold